Duration
2 hrs 15 mins
Closing Date
Until August 31, 2024
Why Watch Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York)?
- Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) is a hilarious musical comedy that takes you on a romantic journey across the city of New York.
- The show features an original score and lyrics by the talented Jim Buchan, an acclaimed composer known for his work in films like The Unseen (2017), and Kit Barne whose works have graced prestigious publications such as Clinic.
- Follow Brit Dougal who meets native New Yorker Robin at the airport. No instant chemistry, but with NYC and a lavish wedding, anything could happen. Book your Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) tickets to see what's next!
Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) will keep you guessing, mingling elements of romance, comedy, and family drama. Penned by the talented Jim Buchan and Kit Barne, this delightful musical moves to The Criterion Theatre after a sold-out stint at The Kiln Theatre. With an original score that perfectly captures the holiday spirit and the undeniable chemistry between the two leads, this show is a must-see for anyone looking for a good laugh and a heartwarming story. Don't miss out, get your tickets to Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) now!
Storyline
The plot follows Dougal, a Brit traveling to New York for his absent father's wedding. At the airport, he meets Robin, the bride's sister, who is a native New Yorker. Although they don't hit it off instantly, the city offers numerous opportunities for shared experiences. With the extravagant wedding nearing, the two have to navigate the bustling city during the peak holiday season, which leads to a series of hilarious and heartwarming events.
Show timings
- Tue, Wed, Thu & Fri: 7:30pm
- Sat: 7:30pm & 2:30pm
- Sun: 3pm
- Show timings for Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) may vary every week. You can check the show timings for your preferred date at the next stage of booking.
Cast & Crew
Leading Roles
Dujonna Gift as Robin
Sam Tutty as Dougal
Writers
Jim Barne
Kit Buchan
Criterion Theatre
The Criterion Theatre is one of the few independent theatres in London’s West End. Actors, directors and producers always love playing the Criterion Theatre. A jewel in Piccadilly, the auditorium curves out in a very intimate manner. Audiences can experience the performers up close and personal in this 150-year-old theater. The Piccadilly Jewel Box has a uniquely magical atmosphere. With the buzzing Piccadilly Circus junction less than a minute away and Central London beckoning, Criterion Theatre is the home of independent productions and unique activity. Both inside and out. Criterion Theatre seating plan will help you find the best seats in the theatre.
Getting There
- Address: 218-223 Piccadilly, St. James's, London W1J 9HR, UK
- By metro:
The nearest tube stations to the theatre are Piccadilly Circus and Leicester Square.
- By train:
Piccadilly Circus (Piccadilly Line and Bakerloo Line) is a minute away from the venue. Trains with codes BDBR, BDVL, FGBN, SHBR, and SHCL stop at the South Brisbane train station.
- By bus:
3, 6, 12, 13, 14, 15, 19, 22, 23, 38, 88, 94, 139, 159, and 453.
Facilities & Accessibility
Amenities: Dining outlets, Cloak room, Toilets, Souvenir shop
Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible, Service animals allowed
Additional Information
Security: Please be aware that for your comfort and security all audience members will be subject to security checks upon arrival at the Criterion Theatre.
Dress Code: Smart and casual wear or semi-formals are recommended. Keep in mind, that most London theatres are air-conditioned throughout the year and can get a bit chilly.
Outside Food: Most theatres do not allow outside food inside the theatres but most of them also have a café or restaurant inside the premises or nearby.
Tickets Redemption
</ul>
Cancellation & Refunds
- These tickets can't be cancelled or rescheduled.






Frequently asked questions
The cost of the musical starts from £18 and will vary depending on the type of seats you choose.
The musical opens on 14 April 2024 at Criterion Theatre.
The musical does not have a strict age limit. However, it is most suitable for children aged 12 and above.
The musical is playing at Criterion Theatre in London.
The musical follows two strangers as they travel across the city of New York to attend a wedding. Romance, comedy, and family drama blend into this heartwarming tale.
The running time of the musical is 2 hrs 15 mins.
The main stars of the musical are Dujonna Gift as Robin and Sam Tutty as Dougal.











































